Dealing with conspiracy narratives in the close social environment – A practical handbook to help the helpers (EU RAN Practitioners)

Authored by Alexander Ritzmann & Ulrike Schiesser

February 2024

Introduction: Conspiracy narratives and conspiratorial thinking
This paper aims at supporting practitioners in the social services sector as well as practitioners in general
who have family members and friends affected by conspiracy narratives. It provides background knowledge on the underlying functionality of conspiracy narratives and their possible links to violent extremism.
Additionally, it gives advice to practitioners on effective strategies for dealing with such narratives. The paper also provides a summary of a toolkit, published by RAN Practitioners in July 2023, on how to deal with conspiracy narratives with your family and friends.
Conspiracy narratives can pose a threat to liberal democracies, as observed in numerous Member States of the European Union. Long before the COVID-19 pandemic and throughout human history, conspiracy
narratives have fuelled conflict, hate and violence, leading to, for example, witch hunts, pogroms, genocides and terrorism. Conspiracy narratives in the European Union today can still foster violence, but more often they contribute to eroding trust in democratic governing institutions and scientific state-of-the-art knowledge.

Download the paper here

Don’t Get Fooled—The Extreme-Right Active Club Network Is Not About Combat Sports

By Alexander Ritzmann, Senior Advisor with the Counter Extremism Project (CEP)

December 14, 2023

On 8 December 2023, two alleged members of the Canadian branch of the Atomwaffen Division (AWD) were arrested in Canada. In a statement, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police said that they participated in the creation of Terrorgram Collective manifestos and Atomwaffen Division (AWD) recruiting videos. In 2021, Atomwaffen Division became a listed terrorist entity in Canada. The statement also highlights that many former Atomwaffen Division members joined Active Club Canada, including the two arrestees.

…..

Read the full article

Hiding in Plain Sight – The Transnational Right-Wing Extremist Active Club Network (CEP Research Report)

Alexander Ritzmann

Counter Extremism Project (CEP)

September 22, 2023

Link for download

Executive Summary
  • This report analyzes the potential threats affiliated with the largest and fast growing transnational right-wing extremist (RWE/REMVE)[1] combat sports network, called Active Clubs. It explores the objectives, strategies, strengths, and weaknesses of this network, which has spread from the U.S. to Canada and to at least 14 countries in Europe within three years.
  • The overall objective of the Active Club White Supremacy 3.0 strategy[2] is the creation of a stand-by militia of trained and capable RWE/REMVE individuals who can be activated when the need for coordinated violent action on a larger scale arises.
  • Over 100 Active Clubs have been created between late 2020 and August 2023, with at least 46 in the United States across 34 U.S. states. At least 46 Active Clubs exist in 14 European countries, and 12 in Canada. The estimated number of members per Active Club is between five and 25.
  • Some Active Clubs in the U.S. are conducting or participating in military-style tactical and casualty care trainings. Members or sympathizers of Active Clubs in France and Estonia appear to be fighting in the Russia-Ukraine war.
  • If Active Clubs are allowed to continue to operate and multiply, the likelihood for targeted political violence and terrorism by their members against supposed enemies of the “white race” (e.g., Jews, people of color, Muslims, and LGTBQI+ people) will increase.
  • A key component of the White Supremacy 3.0 strategy is to hide in plain sight. To avoid, delay, mitigate, or withstand law enforcement interventions, Active Clubs are supposed to present a friendly face to the public. Consequently, network members are asked to avoid threatening behavior or displaying obvious Nazi symbols to appear less relevant to law enforcement. This less aggressive and more mainstream strategy is also meant to help grow the network, in particular from the general public.
  • For the Active Club strategy of hiding in plain sight to work, members should look like regular guys, like the members of the (NSDAP Schutzstaffel) SS did. When recruiting, Active Club members should not talk about Jews and history. Instead, the focus in public should be on brotherhood, community, fitness, and self-defense.
  • Active Club narratives are driven by curated stories of white victimhood and empowerment through white supremacy. Key slogans are “A group of strong white men is a fascist statement in itself”; “The best strategy is to be as unpolitical as possible to be as appealing as possible”; “White unity at every opportunity” and “Make fascism fun”.
  • Active Clubs follow an open network approach, which encourages individuals to start their own independent local group. They are asked to carry out combat sports trainings and illegal political activism like banner drops, stickering, and graffiti tagging to promote a risk-taker mentality and to train operational and logistical capacities like scouting target locations and avoiding law enforcement. Creating local and national RWE/REMVE leadership figures in this process is another main objective.
  • Several Active Club members are or previously were involved in other RWE/REMVE organizations like Patriot Front, Proud Boys, Oath Keepers, Hammerskins, and White Lives Matter.
  • Women play no visible role in U.S. Active Clubs, while Active Clubs in Canada and France have female members.
  • The recent arrest of Robert Rundo, the co-founder and main strategist of the Active Club network, seems to have no direct effect on the growth of the network. Rundo stated himself that the groups would run on their own now and would not need him anymore. 
  • The ongoing growth of the transnational militant Active Club network requires an exchange of local and national threat assessments, investigative strategies, and promising prevention as well as rehabilitation practices between policymakers and law enforcement officials of the affected countries. 

More specific recommendations for policymakers and law enforcement are available upon request.


[1] Officially referred to in the United States of America as “racially or ethnically motivated violent extremism” (REMVE or RMVE)

[2] White Supremacy 3.0, called White Nationalism 3.0 or cultural model 3.0 by the Active Clubs themselves, should be understood in reference to other forms of RWE/REMVE activism, in particular street activism by Skinheads (1.0) and alt-right “keyboard warriors” (2.0).

Financial Strategies of Right-Wing Extremist Organizations and Actors in the United Kingdom and Germany (CEP Report)

The CounterPoint Blog, Alexander Ritzmann

In June 2023, CEP published a study that outlines and analyzes the financial strategies and activities of key right-wing extremist (RWE) organizations and actors in the United Kingdom and in Germany. The United Kingdom and Germany see violent right-wing extremism and terrorism as a major threat to public safety and minority groups. Right-wing extremism often operates in the grey zone between legal and illegal as well as violent and non-violent activities. Political violence, and terrorism in particular, do not exist in a vacuum and require financial resources. Understanding causal and contributing factors as well as the roles of allegedly legally operating key extremist actors is essential for effectively preventing and combating political violence and terrorism.

A connecting and essential component in both countries are entrepreneurs or key actors of extremism. This refers to RWE individuals or groups that have already been holding key roles in leadership, propaganda, recruiting, and financing for a prolonged period. They are often experienced and avoid direct calls for violence or publicly visible command positions in violence-oriented groups. These key actors of extremism rather facilitate and steer events such as Rechtsrock/Rock against Communism (RAC) music events or political activities. They promote narratives of “white victimhood” and “self-defense” and are therefore essential to the milieus that breed RWE violence.

The research focused on legal as well as (potentially) illegal financial activities of those key actors with systemic relevance to the U.K.’s and Germany’s RWE milieus. While the identified financial RWE strategies and activities in the U.K. and Germany appear legal at first sight, the seemly deliberate opaqueness of almost all of them indicates a high likelihood of systematic tax evasion as well as violations of transparency and reporting requirements. Some of these financial strategies do generate significant amounts of income, as shown in another CEP report on RWE financing patterns and networks in Germany. A significant portion of the generated funds are in cash.

Some of the main findings of the report are that RWE key actors in the U.K. have shown a curious pattern of registering and dissolving limited companies (LCs) as well as the use of more innovative online pay-per-engagement/influencer-audience type crowdfunding strategies. Some German RWEs associated with the Reichsbürger movement have been using the U.K.’s LCs as a tool to generate significant earnings in Germany.

In Germany, it is quite possible that due to increasingly effective government and civil society interventions formerly lucrative “old school” income streams like RAC concerts and sales of merchandise could dry out. In such a case, key actors of the German RWE milieus could adopt some of the more innovative financial strategies from RWEs in the U.K.

Since RWE key actors are openly opposing and challenging the authority of the U.K. and the German government, CEP suggested investigations by law enforcement and tax authorities into illegal activities, such as tax evasion or money laundering. These could present an opportunity for the effective disruption of extremist funding, propaganda, and recruiting strategies.

The diversity and innovative strategies of key RWE actors in the U.K. and Germany require an equally broad range of risk mitigating measures and a government financial disruption strategy that target key RWE actors, which could have immediate disruptive effects that could slow down or hinder the financial, propaganda, and recruitment efforts of key RWE stakeholders in both countries.

Transnational Linkages Between Violent Right-Wing Extremism, Terrorism, and Organized Crime (CEP Report)

The CounterPoint Blog, Alexander Ritzmann

In March 2023, CEP published a study demonstrating that several violence-oriented right-wing extremist (VRWE) individuals and groups in Europe and the U.S. engage in or maintain ties with organized crime (OC). Many of the identified cases have a transnational dimension, for example, through cross border activities like the acquisition of illegal drugs for distribution or parallel memberships in VRWE and transnational OC groups. Outlaw Motorcycle Gangs, VRWE-affiliated football hooligan groups, white supremacist prison gangs, and a range of other VRWE individuals and groups are part of such transnational networks, which are particularly visible in Austria, Germany, Poland, Sweden, and the United States.

The study finds that the linkages between VRWE and OC are multifaceted and vary in intensity, ranging from mere operational contacts to supply illegal materials to a full-scale transformation of VRWE structures into OC structures that follow an VRWE ideology. VRWE-OC cooperation seems to be driven by the pragmatic principle of “form follows function.” Even ideologically motivated VRWE are flexible with their “values” and cooperate, e.g., with perceived “non-white” OC actors if it serves their “higher” purpose. Not appreciating this sufficiently can lead to incomplete risk assessments.

Interestingly, there are significant differences in the quantity and quality of identified VRWE-OC linkages between the country chapters. This could mean that such cooperations are strongly connected to national strategies, developments, and opportunities. It could, however, also mean that the smaller number of VRWE-OC linkages found in some countries is the result of an absence of targeted and systematic law enforcement investigations into this phenomenon and a lack of official statistical categories that could reveal such connections.

In general, a “follow the money” approach, which has been successfully deployed against OC and in the prevention and fight against Islamist extremism and terrorism, has not been adopted by any of the governments of the countries analyzed in the study with regard to violent right-wing extremism. To foster a better understanding of the scope and size of the challenges posed by the linkages between violent right-wing extremism and organized crime, data collection, analysis, and sharing practices related to OC activities and strategies by VRWE actors outlined in this study should be improved on the international, European, and national levels. To operationally address the phenomenon’s national and transnational dimensions, Joint VRWE-OC Task Forces should be established on the EU level and on the national levels to better enable targeted investigations. 

CEP Webinar: The Transnational Nexus of Right-Wing Extremism and Organized Crime

YouTube-Link

Presentation (March 29, 2023): Mr. Alexander Ritzmann: Lead author of the study and of the Germany chapter Senior Advisor, Counter Extremism Project (CEP) The new CEP study can be accessed here: https://bit.ly/3ZPt9k1

About the study: Existing studies on the extremism/terrorism-crime nexus in recent years have focused on Islamist extremism and terrorism, while the transnational nexus between right-wing extremism/terrorism and organized crime groups remains under-researched. This gap in knowledge can lead to a misunderstanding of the strategies of right-wing extremists as well as of the risks those actors pose to potential victims and society as a whole.

A new CEP study, commissioned by the Federal Foreign Office of Germany, shows that several violence-oriented right-wing extremist individuals and groups in Europe and the U.S. engage in or maintain ties with organized crime. Many of the identified cases have a transnational dimension, be it through cross-border activities like the acquisition of illegal drugs for distribution or through supposedly legal activities such as co-organizing hate music concerts, including events with a transnational character.

As the study demonstrates, Outlaw Motorcycle Gangs, VRWE-affiliated football hooligan groups, prison gangs, and a range of VRWE individuals and groups are part of transnational networks. Such connections are particularly visible in Austria, Germany, Poland, Sweden, and the U.S. The study aims at informing policymakers working on the prevention and countering of violent extremism or terrorism and organized crime with the goal of fostering a better understanding of the phenomena and to encourage further cooperation between relevant government agencies and civil society organizations.

Die Neonazimafia (ZEIT ONLINE)

Extreme Rechte machen Millionen mit Drogen, Waffen und Prostitution. Doch Ermittler ignorieren oft die Verbindungen zwischen kriminellem Milieu und Rechtsextremisten.

Ein Gastbeitrag von Alexander Ritzmann

6. April 2023

Weblink

Rechtsextreme vernetzen sich über Grenzen hinweg miteinander, aber auch mit klassischen kriminellen Gruppen. Solche transnationalen Netzwerke hat das Counter Extremism Project, ein in Deutschland und den USA arbeitender Thinktank, im Auftrag des Auswärtigen Amtes untersucht. Der Politikwissenschaftler Alexander Ritzmann ist Mitautor dieser Studie.

The December 2022 German Reichsbürger Plot to Overthrow the German Government

CTC Sentinal

March 2023, Volume 16, Issue 3
Alexander Ritzmann

Weblink: https://ctc.westpoint.edu/the-december-2022-german-reichsburger-plot-to-overthrow-the-german-government/

Abstract: The alleged plot against the German government by the Reichsbürger group Patriotic Union, whose key members were arrested on December 7, 2022, is best understood as a thwarted, possible early-stage terrorist plot, rather than a preempted imminent violent coup attempt. The Reichsbürger, who are comprised of different groups and networks, claim that the German state of today does not legally exist. Many Reichsbürger ascribe to a version of the anti-Semitic ‘New World Order;’ others believe in “QAnon.” Some are right-wing extremists. However, the German Reichsbürger are not a movement. They lack structure, unifying narratives, and a common leadership, and their leading adherents do not cooperate with each other. Although the vast majority of Reichsbürger are neither considered violent nor right-wing extremists by German security agencies, the threat posed by a minority of violent and extremist Reichsbürger persists, with German security agencies continuing to thwart alleged violent activity linked to different Reichsbürger groups. Hence, the broad variety of Reichsbürger groups and individuals requires ongoing and focused attention by the German police and intelligence agencies, investigative journalists as well as civil society organizations.

DGAP-CEP Event: The Possibilities and Limitations of the EU’s Digital Services Act | A. Ritzmann

18.01.2023
The German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP) and the Counter Extremism Project (CEP) hosted a hybrid panel discussion on December 13, 2022: “Fighting Extremism and Terrorism on Social Media Platforms: The Possibilities and Limitations of the EU’s Digital Services Act” On November 16, the EU’s long-awaited Digital Services Act (DSA) came into force. It aims to curb the spread of the online hate speech, disinformation, and extremist and terrorist content with which democratic societies are increasingly confronted. At this event, we explored the implications of the DSA for combating extremism on social media platforms. How will it affect existing national regulations such as Germany’s Network Enforcement Act? How will the new legislation impact the technological aspects of the fight against online extremism? How is extremist infrastructure adapting online in the face of regulation? PANELISTS: Anke Schlieker, Project Assistant, Technology and Global Affairs Program, DGAP Dr. Hany Farid, Professor, University of California, Berkeley; Senior Advisor, CEP Alexander Ritzmann, Senior Advisor, CEP; Associate Fellow, DGAP